How do astronauts survive travel through the potentially lethal Van Allen Radiation Belts?
The "conspiracy theory" programs that pop up on TV every now and again
always seem to draw a hefty audience. Let's face it, negative news
generates higher ratings than does positive news. Some people shrug off
such programs, but surprisingly many believe that just because it is on
the "tube," there must be something to it. For example, a recent show
aired on the Fox Network debated whether or not NASA astronauts actually
made it to the moon. Some participants argued that they did not, that our
government faked the moon-landing pictures and hoodwinked the public. As
evidence, they claimed that it would be impossible to protect astronauts
traveling through the Van Allen Radiation Belts, and therefore that
radiation would surely have killed them. Let's take a closer look.
The Van Allen Radiation Belts lie within the Earth's magnetosphere, the
name given to Earth's magnetic environment in space. A popular way of
representing the structure of this magnetized region ("magnetic field")
is by "magnetic field lines" (or "lines of force"), imaginary lines which
at every point give the direction of the magnetic force. It is a familiar
pattern, also produced by iron filings on a sheet of paper placed above a
bar magnet: the lines emerge from near the southern magnetic pole, bend
away near the equator and converge again near the north magnetic pole.
The lines are imaginary, an aid to mapping (like lines of longitude and
latitude on a globe), but in the magnetosphere they have an extra role,
describing the way charged particles move and are trapped. Space away from
Earth is filled with such particles: negative electrons knocked off atoms
by sunlight or collisions, and "positive ions" which are atoms that have
lost one or more electrons. Some are quite fast, able to penetrate
material and damage tissue. Similar particles are emitted by radioactive
substances and are commonly named "radiation," so when energetic particles
were discovered to be magnetically trapped around Earth, they were named
"radiation belts." They spiral around field lines and are attached to
them, like beads to a wire, though they can slowly jump from line to line and
work their way around the Earth. It is the magnetic field which holds them
near Earth--not gravity, which is much too weak.
Are they dangerous? Yes, you would not want to stay within them too long.
Are they an unknown hazard? No, they have been studied from satellites for
decades. To mention just one study, the CRRES (Combined Radiation and
Release Explorer Satellite) of NASA and the USAF in 1990-1 was designed to
map them--and to release some artificial ions, for studying their motion.
The lowest, densest and maybe most dangerous is the inner belt, consisting
of high-energy protons, a byproduct of the drizzle of celestial ions known
as the cosmic radiation. It was this belt that was discovered in 1958 by
the Iowa University team, led by James Van Allen and using the first US
satellites Explorer 1 and 3. Beyond this lies the
"outer belt," lower in energy but with some "killer electrons" as well.
The Sun itself lets loose now and then, unpredictably, blasts of energetic
particles; for astronauts on their way to Mars, those would pose the
greatest danger.
Scientific spacecraft which spend years in the magnetosphere may
accumulate damage, though some last surprisingly long. The space station's
orbit is below the belts, and is protected from solar particles by the
Earth's own magnetic field. The Apollo astronauts, on the other hand,
avoided risk by whizzing through the belt at maximum speed.
David Stern, a physicist at Goddard Space Flight Center, has assembled web
sites providing extensive information about the magnetosphere, space, the
sun, spaceflight and much more (see below). He also answers questions, and
some with their replies are on those sites as well. The airing of "We
Never Landed on the Moon" produced quite a few inquiries.
As Dr. Stern states, the Van Allen Radiation Belt is a tough neighborhood,
and like most such neighborhoods, if you hang around too long, you're
bound to get hurt. But knowing what to expect, you can get by quite well
if you go through it as quickly as possible.
Our old atmosphere does a pretty good job of shielding us from anything
the sun emits, and it stops most cosmic radiation (whose intensity is low
anyway). It's like having a 10 foot thick concrete shield surrounding the
Earth. However, solar eruptions are a special concern during spaceflight,
as interplanetary space can be flooded with energetic particles.
The chances that a solar eruption will occur are higher during the peak
(solar maximum) of the 11-year solar sunspot cycle, which is where we are
now in the current solar cycle. Within the last few days, the Sun has been
particularly active. In fact, one of the largest sunspots and one of the
largest solar flares ever seen were detected by astronomers observing the
Sun. Like most such eruptions, they've produced vivid auroras and
interfered with communications. Though they've never been fatal to humans
in space, solar eruptions are not taken lightly. If a solar storm were in
progress, the launch of a manned mission would be postponed. Even if we
can protect astronauts from most all of the energetic particles, it makes
no sense to put them at an increased risk by launching during a solar
eruption. By the way, the active sun also shortens the orbital lifetimes
of low flying satellites: it emits x-rays which heat the upper atmosphere,
making it swell upwards to where satellites orbit. The space
station "Skylab," a quarter century ago, re-entered ahead of schedule
because of the Sun's activity.
Dr. Stern calculated that the solar cells of a satellite passing through
the inner Van Allen belt, shielded by only 1 mm of glass, would receive
about 25 rad of radiation per pass. Particles in the outer belt are less
penetrating. Anything over about 200 rad is dangerous to humans and about
500 rad can be lethal. Fortunately, it doesn't take much shielding to
deter the particles, and the shielding doesn't need to be constructed of
rare or exotic metals.
The bottom line is that even though radiation from the Sun can be lethal
to humans in space, it has not prevented us from going to the moon or
anywhere else.
One of Dr. Stern's websites is "The Great Magnet
Earth," http://www-spof.gsfc.nasa.gov/earthmag/demagint.htm
05 April 2001